Ask a Guy: When a Guy is Jealous… post image

Ask a Guy: When a Guy is Jealous…

I’ve been with my boyfriend for 4 months and he’s been acting more and more jealous.  At first, I found it sweet, but this weekend he snooped through my phone and accusing me of talking to other men.

I can tell you with complete honesty that I haven’t talked to any other guys… the thought doesn’t even cross my mind.  I kept telling my boyfriend that I’m only interested in him, but he seems cold and withdrawn now.  It’s like I’m being punished for a crime I didn’t commit.

Is this normal jealousy or is this something beyond?  Can you tell me what to do when a guy is jealous?

Some jealousy  in a relationship can be fine.  You could even go so far as to call jealousy a good sign in certain contexts.

The question is: When is jealousy appropriate, how much, and when is it a good sign?

One of the greatest gifts we get from being in a relationship is that it encourages us to grow in ways that we may not have grown if we were single.

Letting go of my own jealousy issues, insecurities, and fears was part of my own growth in relationships.  In my early twenties, the thought of being cheated on was a nightmare scenario for me.

Obviously I wouldn’t be happy with being cheated on if it happened to me now, but I wouldn’t take it personally.  I wouldn’t interpret it as meaning something about me, like I was less of a man, a fool, or a chump.  It isn’t a worry or fear that keeps me up at night.

Part of my own growth was realizing (really realizing) that the actions of someone else has nothing to do with me.

As with all things in relationships, the most painful areas are the ones where we feel like another person’s actions mean something about us.

These days I have a motto about people and relationships: People will always do whatever they want.

MOREAsk a Guy: Why Did He Cheat?

Sure, they might feel bad about it afterwards.  Sure, they will have some elaborate rationalization for why they did what they did.

So again:  At the end of the day, the fact remains true for all humans:  People will always do whatever they want.

The reason I’m telling you all this is because, before I came to this realization myself, it would have been impossible for me to think about my jealousy rationally.

It is nearly every man’s worst fear to be the chump of a situation.

Sure, it’s true for all people, but it’s the deepest kind of pain for a man when he’s played for a fool, taken advantage of, or gives his heart to someone who toys with it.  Most men would rather be single forever than played as  a fool by a woman.

I would even go so far as to say it’s biological.

In psychology studies, it’s been shown that men are most jealous when they believe there’s some physical connection between the woman they’re with and some other man.  This could be triggered by that man touching her in some way or giving her a hug.

Women are most jealous when they perceive some sort of emotional connection between the man she’s with and another woman.  This could be triggered by him worrying about the other woman’s feelings, him taking care of the other woman in some loving way, or saying something to the other woman in an affectionate manner.

Jealousy is biologically ingrained in us, but that does not absolve anyone from being completely responsible for their emotions and how they act on their emotions.

It is worth pointing out why  jealousy is part of our emotional makeup…

Biologically speaking, a man wouldn’t want to fall in love with a woman who cheats on him and is impregnated by another man, and then raise a child or children that are not his genetic seed.

From the perspective of evolution, that man’s genes become extinct from the gene pool.  Genetically speaking, this is death – his genes do not pass on, he is weeded out from a future genetic legacy.

Similarly, a woman does not want to be impregnated by a man who then runs off with another woman, leaving her to raise the child on her own.  In today’s world, this would be highly inconvenient. Hundreds or thousands of years ago, this was a guaranteed death sentence.

MOREAsk a Guy: My Boyfriend Flirts With Other Women

While these scenarios might seem dramatic and extreme in today’s world, jealousy was designed as a guard against the very harsh realities of yesterday’s world.

While you were reading about the scenario of being impregnated and then abandoned, most women would have some powerful emotional reaction to that thought.  Maybe anger, maybe horror, maybe despair.  In that same way, a man is equally horrified by the thought of raising some other man’s genetic seed.

Bottom line:  Jealousy is programmed into us biologically.

At the same time, we learn as children that we can’t throw temper tantrums.  We learn how to control our impulsive emotional reactions and respond to things effectively as adults.

In a relationship, it’s our greatest service to one another to compassionately guide our partner through this growth… and to allow them to guide us.

Ultimately, all of us must grow out of, and transcend, our impulsive jealous reactions.  However, we might not be there yet… and our partner might not either.  Being able to accept your partner where they are in their own growth is a huge part of having a successful relationship.

You had asked if this is normal jealousy or something more.  So let’s talk about signs a guy is jealous.

In most cases, if a guy is going to show his jealousy, he’ll show it by making some sarcastic comment about another guy or “joking” about you hooking up with that other guy.  Some guys will just have the jealous thought internally and then as a reaction to their jealous thoughts, they go cold to you emotionally.  You also might notice his demeanor and actions have a hostile or attacking quality towards you when he’s jealous.

The question is:  When is his jealousy going too far?  The answer is when he tries to control you.

Men (or women for that matter) become controlling when they’re afraid of something happening.  A guy might be afraid that you’ll cheat on him with a guy friend of yours… so he forbids you from talking to that guy.  He might be afraid that guys are chatting with you on Facebook… so he forces you to constantly announce your relationship status on Facebook.  He threatens one of your guy friends because he’s afraid you might be attracted to that guy.

Relationships are about guidance, not control.  The moment that someone invades your privacy or threatens you with a punishment if you don’t do what they want you to, then they’re no longer a guiding companion in a relationship with you–they are allowing their out-of-control emotions to rule them and, by extension, rule you.

MOREAsk a Guy: He Caught Me Snooping

Their emotions are their responsibility.  It can’t be any other way.

If you do give in to their demands, you’ll end up losing a part of yourself.  They will have effectively taken color out of your world and as a result, color out of you.

You’ll lose a part of yourself (quite likely the part that attracted them in the first place) and, in an ultimate irony, they’ll end up feeling less attracted to you.

Additionally, you’ll resent them for controlling you, limiting you, and taking away something or someone that you enjoy in your life. That resentment will poison the relationship to some degree . The more control and limitation they successfully impose on you, the more you’ll resent them.

So really, allowing a jealous man to control you isn’t just a bad idea… it ceases to be a relationship at that point.

A relationship is only a relationship when both people realize that they themselves are responsible for their own emotions… and that there’s no amount of control over another person that could ever put out the flames of raw, burning, unconscious emotions.  The only solution to put out that fire is to shine the line of consciousness onto their own emotional restlessness… and make peace with it.

Relationships require that both people really are ready to have a relationship.  It isn’t easy, but refusing to be controlled is actually what’s best for the relationship.

A child might whine and beg for their parent to give them candy all the time… but that’s not what’s best for the child.  Sometimes denying what the other person wants is what’s best for the relationship.  However, it’s certainly not the easiest choice.

The best choice is to continue being as you are.  It’s best to be open to your relationship partner as much as you can be, but in the cases where they want to control you or change you, your best option is to see it as an opportunity to learn how to love and accept you as you are.

If they don’t want to lose you, they’ll grow.  If they don’t care if they lose you and would prefer to cling to their emotional reactions/fears/worries, well, then you will have identified that they are not ready for a relationship with you.

Sure, you might have titles, celebrate anniversaries, and buy each other gifts on your birthdays, but those are just surface-level wrapping paper.  True relationships require both people to be ready and to have the capacity to compassionately get one another to grow… not to give into one another’s fear-based demands.

My central point is that you can’t allow controlling behavior into your relationship or it will very quickly lead your relationship into disaster.

When it comes to jealousy, it can be a huge warning sign when ... (continued - Click to keep reading Ask a Guy: When a Guy is Jealous…)

9 comments… add one

Leave Your Comment Now...


Great article! If I’d known this when I was 21, I’ve have avoided wasting 5 years with a controlling, manipulative, lying, cheating ex. He was very jealous of me in waves – checked my accounts (email/FB), my phone, had me FOLLOWED a couple times, pushed me to act in ways that just aren’t ME (mostly dressing extra provocatively) because he liked the attention I got, but he was still paranoid I’d cheat on him. I found out after finding my self confidence and self-worth and leaving him that he’d cheated on me off and on throughout the relationship. And all the times he got super jealous over me were around times when he was cheating on me.

Not saying that someone who is paranoid you’re going to cheat is cheating themselves (especially if you know they were cheated on in the past since that is just as likely a cause of excessive jealousy in the next relationship), but it’s definitely something that would cross my mind.

I would never tolerate that from a guy these days. A little jealousy is normal and healthy, and can be a sign that a guy genuinely has feelings for you, but when a man starts trying to monitor you and tries to force you to change the way you act/dress/etc – that’s a line that should not be crossed (and that goes for women doing the same to men as well). A well-adjusted adult should be able to control their reactions to their emotions, and recognize if something is becoming an over-reaction.

Reply April 12, 2013, 2:27 pm

Eric Charles

Good comment – thanks for that.

Reply April 12, 2013, 9:10 pm


Eric, great article but there is something I don’t understand. You advise us girls to keep our options open and to date different guys if we are not locked up but at the same time you don’t think it’s right if the girl you are seeing is seeing other guys? I’m a bit confused.
And btw, to me it hurts more to see or find out my man has been physical with another woman. I don’t consider it cheating if it hasn’t escalated physically. But that might be just me.

Reply April 12, 2013, 3:37 am

Eric Charles

No problem – I will clarify.

First, in my writing I explain that it’s the best strategy to be single and looking until a guy clearly and unambiguously locks you down in a relationship where you are both on the same page.

That doesn’t necessarily mean date different guys – it *can* mean that… but it doesn’t. The strategic power actually comes from you not acting like you’re locked down until you are… it’s a mindset.

I’m not sure where you think I say that I don’t think it’s right if the girl I’m seeing is seeing other guys. It actually did “work” on me, so to speak… it was only a problem when her actual boyfriend (who I didn’t know existed) showed up in the middle of the night while I was in her bed. That was a situation and that would be a situation to be avoided.

She wasn’t my girlfriend – she didn’t owe me anything and she wasn’t breaking any promises to me. Even with everything I understand about relationship dynamics, I still did “chase” her until I realized the situation – the particular girl I’m thinking of wasn’t going to leave her boyfriend for me so that was that.

Anyway… I’m kind of off on a tangent, but I hope that helps explain things…

Reply April 12, 2013, 9:22 pm


Thank you Eric! But if it’s a decent guy who really likes me and he finds out I’m seeing (or sleeping) with another one won’t this stop him from wanting to commit to me (like thinking I’m a slut, player, etc.)? Won’t his jealousy stop him from wanting anything with me after he finds out he’s not the only one? Won’t I look cheap? After all, why would he risk being with me if that means (in his mind) that it’s possible for me to lie to him and make him look after a child that is not his? Thank you!

Reply April 12, 2013, 10:24 pm

Cheeky Mary

Dating several men may include kissing them but it shouldn’t include sleeping with them. Until a man is exclusive with you, then you are free to do what you want (but a respectful girl wouldn’t be sleeping around if she wanted a long term relationship). Once he claims you (that sounds so caveman but oh so hot) then you eliminate all the other men and get exclusive with him (including sleeping with him).

Eric hates when we say this but dont sleep with a man until you’re exclusive. He is the gateway to a relationship and you are the gateway to sex….he wants the challenge, dont disappoint him like many women these days are doing.


Reply April 15, 2013, 8:12 pm

Eric Charles

Hmmm… that would be an inaccurate way to describe my stance (regarding your second paragraph).

An accurate way to describe my stance what you recommend is: I think it’s bad advice.

April 15, 2013, 11:33 pm


Well, I’m still confused if it’s OK to sleep with several men if no one has locked you down? Isn’t that the fastest way to become a girl who is not considered relationship material?

April 16, 2013, 12:51 am


Oh, bumer! I am a jelous person myself. I really have to work on that! =/

thnk u, Eric for the insight! :)

Reply April 11, 2013, 6:50 pm

Leave a Comment